Comments on: Project 1: Contrast http://golancourses.net/2010spring/01/27/project-1-contrast/ Carnegie Mellon University / Spring 2010 Mon, 10 May 2010 03:41:45 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=4.5.3 By: placebo http://golancourses.net/2010spring/01/27/project-1-contrast/comment-page-1/#comment-49 Thu, 28 Jan 2010 15:02:26 +0000 http://golancourses.net/2010spring/?p=2133#comment-49 Hi Justin – here are the PiratePad comments from the critique:

I like the colors. Nice job.

The images are very captivating. Cool idea. You put a lot of information into that grid of photos… (day taken, color pallet, etc.) I want to play with this.

I like the logo. Blending CMYK is always pretty.

Very pretty– I like how you have your own website for your project.  I like how you’re looking at your data over time.  Maybe have a color pallet for all the pictures for a certain tag on a specific day.  I like how your data is all live too!  Very cool. 🙂  I agree with the comment below, I think you should explain somewhere how you generate your pallet.  I like your idea of having each person have their own color pallet bar…cute play on bar codes. -Amanda

Are you computing the color palettes yourself? How? (by what method)
How do you select 40 photos for a certain day, given the thousands of photos that are uploaded per day (even those with the same tag)?
Reminded of a few projects:
10×10 by Jonathan Harris http://www.tenbyten.org/
Squircles by Simon King http://www.currentform.com/squircles/
Flickr Image Blending http://infosthetics.com/archives/2006/06/flickr_image_merging_blending.html
Flickr Average Faces (from Hot or Not) http://www.flickr.com/photos/pierre_tourigny/146532556/ 

Is the default to show the dates one year apart? I wonder what the value of that is because especially with nature pictures I expect that the colors would be generally the same, because of the time of year.

I don’t know if the color palette is interesting over time periods. The content of the photos vs time is probably more interesting

Are you selecting the 40 most recent, or the 40 most relevant, or the 40 more interesting?
-Agree, would like to see this sorted by 40 most interesting, or most viewed.

I think you should be consistent as to which date comes before and which comes after.-Jon
Also, would it be possible to display more than two? A whole range across several months/years might be interesting.
Also, can you talk more about what you did in the past few weeks vs. before that?
Very clean design, classy.

Vivid color, simple yet classy design, I loved it.

To deal with the range bug, why not just grab all photos after one date, all photos before the other date, and delete all that aren’t in both sets? Depends on how narrow your range is and how large the result set is, I suppose. -SB

]]>